Learn
The Kettei failure modes
A failure mode is a named way in which a decision goes wrong after it has been approved. Kettei groups its failure modes by the phase of the Ishi Spiral in which each one surfaces, and anchors each on a case with a public record.
Most approved decisions that fail were made with care. The programme kept an owner and the budget kept an owner, and the decision that authorised both was no longer anyone's job as a decision. The failure modes describe the forms that absence takes, from a decision with no Owner to a review that changes no decision.
Each mode is read through a third-party case with a public inquiry, a regulator's finding, a court judgment or a peer-reviewed source behind it. The cases are examples. The subject of each page is the failure mode, and the question it puts to a decision still in flight.
Pages in this group
- Decision vacancy No single person holds the decision's continuing validity. The case is the British Army's Ajax programme, where the owner's box had a name in it throughout.
- Coupling blindness 2 coupled decisions are treated as independent. The case is Novopay, where the real go-live decision was made almost 3 months before go-live.
- Assumption drift The world moves while the decision stays put. The case is Peloton's Ohio factory, built on a forecast the company had already cut.
- Trigger register decay A register of triggers degrades from adaptive sensing to compliance checking. The case is Equifax, blind to its own portal for 19 months.
- Normalisation of deviance Deviations come to be treated as normal variation. The case is Challenger, where each flight review judged new erosion against erosion already accepted.
- Escalation of commitment Persistence on the strength of prior investment. The case is the London Stock Exchange's Taurus project, with the experiments of Staw and of Simonson and Staw.
- Ungoverned persistence Work goes on with no conditions defined for stopping. The cases are Knight Capital and the NHS National Programme for IT.
- Governance theatre The appearance of governance with no monitoring of whether decisions remain valid. The case is Carillion.
- Resulting A review error related to the modes, in which a decision is graded by its outcome. The term is Annie Duke's, and the page shows how the Reflect phase reads the decision record first.
The table as published
The table below was published with the launch essay on 1 October 2026, where it lists 16 failure modes. Each row keeps the published wording. A last column adds the published case and where to read it, on this site or in the original essay on Substack.
| Phase | Failure mode | What it looks like | Case, and where to read it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decide | Decision Vacancy | No single person holds the decision's continuing validity. "Who is driving this?" | Ajax |
| Decide | Authority Capture | Authority taken in a crisis stays after the crisis, and commitments made inside execution are never declared as decisions. | The Prevention of Terrorism Act 1974, on Substack |
| Decide | Strategic-Tactical Chasm | A board decision reaches delivery as a task list, with no scope or conditions the people doing the work can govern against. | Target Canada, on Substack |
| Decide | Coupling Blindness | 2 coupled decisions are treated as independent. One changes and the other never hears. | Novopay |
| Forge | Unforged Governance | A practice is adopted and adapted before anyone drilled it to competence. | General Motors and NUMMI, on Substack |
| Forge | Documentation-Reality Divergence | The written process and the process people actually run have separated. | Piper Alpha, on Substack |
| Forge | Capability-Governance Mismatch | Decision authority grows faster than the capability to govern it. | Uber, on Substack |
| Persist | Assumption Drift | The world moved and the decision stayed put. "We decided this last year." | Peloton |
| Persist | Trigger Register Decay | Triggers sit on paper and nobody watches the register. | Equifax |
| Persist | Normalisation of Deviance | Deviations become background noise. "That error rate is normal for us." | Challenger |
| Persist | Signals Ignored | The trigger fires and the owner does not act. | Mid Staffordshire, on Substack |
| Persist | Escalation of Commitment | Persisting because of what has been spent. "We have come too far to stop." | Taurus |
| Persist | Ungoverned Persistence | No triggers and no abort criteria, so nothing defines when to stop. | Knight Capital |
| Reflect | Governance Theatre | Every dashboard green and every forum held, with no decision ever changed by either. | Carillion |
| Reflect | Reflection Theatre | The post-mortem is filed, and 12 months later the same failure recurs. | Columbia, on Substack |
| Reflect | Institutional Moralisation | Questioning the decision reads as questioning the institution, so it is never revalidated. | The Post Office and Horizon, on Substack |
The essays also use the name authority leakage, where the authority to commit an endeavour drains into execution and the choices made there go unrecorded as decisions. The published table holds that pattern inside Authority Capture. Its case is The Silent Decision.
How the modes connect
The modes are defined one at a time, and the published essays also record which modes open the way for others. Trigger register decay and governance theatre each enable the other, and the pair lets deviations pass as normal variation. On that reading, several modes that surface in Persist begin earlier, in Forge.
A register starts to go stale when whoever keeps it was not taught why each trigger was set. A signal goes unanswered where the team was not drilled on what a fired trigger requires. Forge failures stay out of sight until the capability left unbuilt is needed under pressure.
A chain also gives the repair an order. At Equifax, on Kettei's reading, the committee's finding of blindness traces back to an unfilled role. The question for a decision in flight is which check on it depends on another check that has already failed.
Read the originals
The Kettei Decision Digests gather the failure-mode essays by theme. The 5 are Digest 2: Failures of Formation, Digest 3: Failures of Capability, Digest 4: Failures of Stopping, Part 1, Digest 5: Failures of Stopping, Part 2 and Digest 6: Failures of Honesty.
The chains between modes are set out in How Failure Cascades of 12 November 2026. The table is held as a one-page resource at The failure modes, and the sources behind each mode are gathered at The research behind the failure modes.
From the essay Kettei: After the Thud of a Rubber Stamp on Kettei on Substack, 1 October 2026.

Kettei
The Discipline of Governed Intent
