Kettei term
Abort criteria
Abort criteria are the conditions, written in advance, under which a decision is revoked. Each is binary, observable and owned, and is set when the decision is formed, before sunk cost builds up.
A decision holds 7 properties before it becomes Active, and abort criteria are among the 7. It needs at least one criterion. A criterion is tuned to the stopping conditions that fit its own decision. It is cheapest to write before the money goes in, while stopping still costs little and no reputation is attached to the decision yet.
Others may propose abort criteria, such as the sponsor or the chief financial officer, and the Owner must agree to each one. Without a written condition, the people inside a running decision are the worst placed to say where the line was. Kettei names the resulting failure mode ungoverned persistence, in which work goes on because the conditions for stopping were not defined.
The trigger and the abort
A trigger is the andon cord, and the abort is the outcome. Anyone watching a trigger may pull the cord, which puts a question to the decision's Owner. The Owner answers in flight with AHA (pronounced A-Hey), choosing to Adjust, Hold or Abort. Hold means hold the line, so the decision stands and effort continues.
When an abort criterion is met, the Owner, and only the Owner, declares the abort. The decision moves from Active to Revoked with no revalidation. A trigger in the validity boundary is gentler. It lets the Owner suspend the decision for revalidation, after which the decision may return to Active.
The case
On the morning of 1 August 2012, Knight Capital's automated order router began processing 212 small retail orders. In roughly 45 minutes it sent millions of orders into the market, and the firm lost more than $460 million. The figures are from the Securities and Exchange Commission's order of 16 October 2013.
The warnings came early. From about 8:01 that morning an internal system sent automated emails that referenced the router and an error, and 97 of those emails reached a group of Knight staff before the market opened at 9:30. Knight had not designed the emails as alerts.
The order found that the firm "did not have procedures in place to halt SMARS's operations in response to its own aberrant activity." For 45 minutes the router kept going while capable people tried to diagnose it live.
What a written condition produces
Since 2009 a United States weapons programme with a critical cost breach must be terminated unless the Secretary of Defense certifies it in writing. The Congressional Research Service counts 24 critical breaches from 2007 to 2015, and in its own words, "Generally, a Nunn-McCurdy breach does not result in a program being cancelled."
Each of those breaches still set machinery moving. The statute requires a root-cause analysis and puts the choice to continue in front of one official, who has 60 days to sign for it. A condition written in advance made a conversation due on a clock, and someone with a name had to answer for the outcome on the record. Kettei claims that smaller yield, because the record supports it.
The experimental record points the same way. In 1992 Itamar Simonson and Barry Staw found that participants who wrote down minimum targets straight after a first choice, before any results, put less new money into the losing product. Even with targets, nearly 40% of the new money went to the product that had missed its targets.
The question to ask
Knight Capital had 45 minutes, and other commitments run for years on the same missing line. Which decision is running now with no written condition for stopping it, and who would switch it off?
Read the original
45 minutes was published on Kettei on Substack on 6 October 2026. The record on stopping rules is set out in The Honest Yield of 4 November 2026, and both are gathered with Nobody Wrote Down When to Stop in Kettei Decision Digest 5: Failures of Stopping, Part 2.
Sources
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (2013) In the Matter of Knight Capital Americas LLC. Release No. 34-70694, 16 October 2013. Establishes the orders, the loss, the 97 emails and the finding on halting the router.
- Peters, H. M. and O'Connor, C. V. (2016) The Nunn-McCurdy Act: Background, Analysis, and Issues for Congress. Congressional Research Service report R41293, updated 12 May 2016. Establishes the breach counts and the certification process.
- Simonson, I. and Staw, B. M. (1992) Deescalation strategies: A comparison of techniques for reducing commitment to losing courses of action. Journal of Applied Psychology 77(4), 419-426. DOI 10.1037/0021-9010.77.4.419. Establishes the effect of minimum targets set before results.
From the essay 45 minutes on Kettei on Substack, 6 October 2026.

Kettei
The Discipline of Governed Intent
